Erica GrossmanDouglas Elliman Real Estate
Erica GrossmanDouglas Elliman Real Estate
A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated 1882 Gothic Victorian set on a landscaped .46-acre parcel in one of Sag Harbor Village's most charming and quiet locations.
Surrounded by historic turn-of-the-century homes, this architectural gem showcases timeless details: deep eaves, multiple gables, a striking turret, and dramatic Victorian windows that fill the home with natural light. The current residence offers approximately 2,500 SF of recently renovated living space, featuring 3 bedrooms, 4 full and one half bath, soaring 11-foot ceilings, a detached garage, and a 45′ × 12′ heated pool with an electric cover.
The property also comes with permits in place for a substantial expansion, a rare chance to create a true Sag Harbor Village compound while enjoying a fully renovated historic home today.
Approved plans let you expand well beyond the current home, adding bedroom suites, living space, a gym, a pool house, and a studio.
Plus a lower level, with room for additional bedroom suites, living space, and a gym.
With a powder room and an outdoor shower, beside the heated pool.
A flexible, standalone studio to complete the compound.
The existing residence alongside the approved plans for the expansion: site plan, every level, elevations, the pool house and the studio. Tap any sheet to enlarge. The full survey is available on request.
Once a storied whaling port, Sag Harbor is the Hamptons at its most authentic, a walkable village of historic homes, a working harbor, independent shops, and celebrated dining, with bay beaches just minutes away. 37 John Street sits on one of the Village's quietest, most cherished streets.
37 John Street is offered co-exclusively. For private viewings, floor plans, survey, and all inquiries, either agent is glad to help by appointment.
Ranked among the top one or two agents in the Hamptons since 2013, with two decades of experience and a refined eye.
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, blending a passion for preservation with deep connections across the Hamptons.
Now available in Sag Harbor Village. Contact Erica Grossman for more information or to arrange a viewing of 37 John Street.